Skip to content
TrkShp

SHIPPING PROFITABILITY MATHS

Shipping cheap items in Australia without losing money

Cheap products lose money on shipping because every parcel has a cost floor, the postage for your smallest satchel plus packaging and packing time, and that floor stays the same whether the item inside is worth $14 or $140. The fix starts with one number: your break-even order value, the order size below which free or cheap shipping costs you more than the product earns. Work that out, then use bundles, order-value pricing and a leaner parcel to get small orders above it.

This guide shows the maths with a worked example and the decision rules that follow from it.

Why cheap items hurt more

Most of what it costs to send a parcel doesn't care what's in it. At the time of writing, Australia Post says parcel prices depend on weight, dimensions, delivery zone and speed of service (business postage costs). The price of your product isn't on that list. Nor does it change your packaging or the minutes it takes to pick and pack the order.

So a low-priced product and an expensive one that fit in the same satchel cost you the same to send. All figures in this post are illustrative and exclude GST. Say your smallest parcel costs you:

Postage (smallest satchel, say)   $9.00
Packaging                         $0.80
Pick, pack and label              $2.20
True cost floor                  $12.00

Our guide to true shipping cost per order explains each line, and pick and pack cost per order shows how to put a figure on the labour. You can also fold in payment fees on shipping and an allowance for parcels that go wrong; they're left out here to keep the numbers easy to follow.

Now compare that floor with two products sent in the same satchel:

$14.00 item:  $12.00 ÷ $14.00 = 86% of the order value
$80.00 item:  $12.00 ÷ $80.00 = 15% of the order value

Same parcel, same cost. On the cheap item, shipping is nearly the whole sale.

Find your break-even order value

The number that matters is how big an order has to be before its product margin can pay for the parcel:

Break-even order value = true cost floor ÷ gross margin %

Gross margin here means what's left of the order value after the cost of the goods, as a percentage. Say your products run at a 60% gross margin:

Break-even order value = $12.00 ÷ 0.60 = $20.00

Below $20.00 ex GST, an order with free shipping loses money before you've paid for anything else: rent, software, ads, your own time. Break-even isn't a goal, so add the profit you want each order to leave behind. If you want at least $5.00 left after shipping:

Target order value = ($12.00 + $5.00) ÷ 0.60 = $17.00 ÷ 0.60 = $28.33

Two things move this number:

  • A lower margin pushes it up. At 40% margin, break-even is $12.00 ÷ 0.40 = $30.00.
  • A bigger or heavier parcel pushes it up. If your cheap products need a box rather than a satchel, use that parcel's cost as the floor.

Use the cost of the parcel your low-value orders actually go in, not your average parcel.

Worked example: a $14 product

A made-up store sells a $14.00 item (ex GST) that costs $5.60 to buy in, so the product margin is $8.40 (60%). It fits in the smallest satchel, with a true cost floor of $12.00.

Here's what one order leaves behind under three shipping choices:

Shipping choice Product margin Shipping charged Parcel cost Left after shipping
Free shipping $8.40 $0.00 $12.00 −$3.60
Flat $6.95 $8.40 $6.95 $12.00 +$3.35
Charge full cost $8.40 $12.00 $12.00 +$8.40

Checking each row: $8.40 + $0.00 − $12.00 = −$3.60. $8.40 + $6.95 − $12.00 = $3.35. $8.40 + $12.00 − $12.00 = $8.40.

Free shipping on a single item loses $3.60 every time. Charging full cost protects the margin, but asking $12.00 to ship a $14.00 item is a hard sell at checkout. The flat $6.95 is a subsidy you've chosen: it gives away $5.05 of shipping cost per order and keeps $3.35.

Now the same store offers the item as a three-pack for $36.00, a small discount on three singles at $42.00. Three units cost $16.80 to buy in, so the product margin is $36.00 − $16.80 = $19.20. The three-pack still fits the smallest satchel; packing takes a bit longer, so handling rises to $2.60:

Parcel cost = $9.00 + $0.80 + $2.60 = $12.40

Three-pack, free shipping:  $19.20 − $12.40 = +$6.80
Three-pack, flat $6.95:     $19.20 + $6.95 − $12.40 = +$13.75

One single with free shipping loses $3.60. Three in one parcel with free shipping makes $6.80. The parcel barely changed; the order got big enough to carry it.

Decision rules for low-value products

  1. Know your break-even order value. Work it out for the parcel your cheap items ship in. Every other decision hangs off it.
  2. Don't offer free shipping below it. If you run a free-shipping threshold, set it at or above your target order value, not at a round number that feels generous. Our guide to setting a free shipping threshold covers the full method, and the free shipping threshold calculator gives you a starting figure.
  3. Price small orders closer to cost. Shopify lets you create rates based on order amount, according to its guide to setting up shipping rates, so orders under your break-even value can pay a rate nearer the true cost while bigger orders pay less or nothing. If you use calculated rates, a minimum shipping price stops the smallest parcels being quoted below what they cost you.
  4. Make the second item easy. Multi-buy pricing, bundles and "add one more" products near checkout all spread the same parcel cost over more margin. The three-pack above turned a loss into a profit with no change to postage.
  5. Shrink the floor. You can't change postage much, but you can choose the smallest packaging that fits, buy it in bulk and speed up packing. Our free satchel vs box price checker shows whether a satchel or a box is cheaper for a given parcel.
  6. Check whether it can go as a letter. Some small, flat products don't need a parcel at all. At the time of writing, Australia Post's business letters page says letters can only contain flexible items, and anything rigid or over the letter size and weight limits is treated as a parcel. Read the current limits and tracking options before you switch, because a lost item you have to replace can wipe out the saving.

Common mistakes

Pricing shipping from your average order. If your average order is $60 but a third of orders are a single $14 item, a free-shipping offer that works on average loses money on every one of those small orders. Look at the small orders on their own.

Treating shipping as a percentage of the price. A percentage markup on postage, or a shipping charge set as a share of the order, gets smaller exactly where the fixed costs bite hardest. Fixed costs need a fixed dollar amount to cover them.

Ignoring the cost of goods. Break-even depends on margin, not price. A $14 item at 75% margin ($10.50) needs a $16.00 order to cover a $12.00 parcel; the same item at 40% margin ($5.60) needs $30.00.

To check that last pair: $12.00 ÷ 0.75 = $16.00, and $12.00 ÷ 0.40 = $30.00.

Where TrkShp fits

If you quote live Australia Post rates, the smallest orders are where a wrong quote hurts most. TrkShp quotes live domestic Australia Post Parcel Post and Express Post rates at Shopify checkout, picks a satchel when it's cheaper than a box, and lets you set a markup and a minimum price so small parcels can't be quoted below cost. It quotes parcel services only, so it won't price a letter. The preview shows what checkout will charge; your Australia Post invoice is still the final word on what you paid.

Key takeaways

  • Every parcel has a cost floor that doesn't shrink with the product's price; in the example it was $12.00, or 86% of a $14 sale.
  • Break-even order value = true cost floor ÷ gross margin %. At $12.00 and 60%, that's $20.00 ex GST; for $5.00 profit after shipping it's $28.33.
  • Free shipping on one $14 item lost $3.60; a three-pack in the same satchel made $6.80.
  • Set free-shipping thresholds above break-even, price small orders closer to cost, and make multi-item orders easy.
  • Use the cost of the parcel your cheap items actually ship in, not your average parcel.

For how shipping fits into the profit on a whole order, see our guide to shipping profitability. Want to see what checkout would charge for your smallest orders? See how TrkShp works.

Frequently asked questions

Why does shipping cost more than my product?

Because every parcel has a fixed floor of postage for your smallest satchel or box, plus packaging and packing time, and that floor doesn't shrink when the item is cheap. On a low-priced product the floor can be most of the order value.

What order value do I need to offer free shipping?

At least your true cost to send the parcel divided by your gross margin percentage. If a parcel costs you $12.00 all in and your margin is 60%, an order needs to be worth $20.00 ex GST just to break even on free shipping, before any other costs.

How do I stop losing money on small orders?

Charge shipping closer to cost on orders below your break-even value, encourage multi-item orders with bundles or multi-buy pricing, set any free-shipping threshold above break-even, and cut the packaging and handling part of the parcel cost.

Can I send small products as a letter instead of a parcel?

Sometimes. At the time of writing, Australia Post says letters can only contain flexible items, and rigid items or anything over the letter size and weight limits is treated as a parcel. Check its current letter rules and tracking options before you rely on it.