Skip to content
TrkShp

OPERATIONS AND PACKAGING

Lost and damaged parcels: how to budget for the cost

Lost and damaged parcels cost far more than the item inside. Each one usually means replacement stock, a second lot of postage, packing it again and someone's time sorting it out, and an Australia Post claim only gets some of that back. The fix isn't to panic about it. It's to measure it, build a small allowance into every order, and protect the few orders where one loss would really hurt.

This guide shows what goes into the cost, works out a per-order allowance in AUD, and gives a simple rule for when Extra Cover is worth paying for.

What a lost or damaged parcel really costs

When a parcel goes missing or arrives broken, most stores send a replacement or refund the customer first and chase the claim later. Either way, these are the cost lines:

  • Replacement stock at what it cost you, not the retail price.
  • Second postage for the replacement parcel.
  • Packaging and pick-pack for the replacement.
  • Customer service time: the emails, the tracking checks, arranging the resend.
  • Claim time: gathering evidence and lodging the claim with Australia Post.
  • The original outbound costs. The first postage, packaging and packing are already spent, just as they are with a return.

Against that, you may recover something: compensation if your claim is accepted, and sometimes a postage refund.

The one figure most stores never work out is the total. A store that resends without fuss sees each incident as a nuisance, not a cost line. Add a few months of them up and it usually becomes a number worth pricing in.

What Australia Post covers by default

At the time of writing, Australia Post says most of its services include $100 of cover for loss or damage, that claims are assessed on a case-by-case basis, and that a refund of postage may also be payable. For more than that, you can buy Extra Cover, priced per $100 of the item's value, up to $5,000, though some services have lower limits.

Its compensation page also lists situations that aren't covered at the time of writing, including parcels with no proof of lodgement and items that weren't adequately packed. Check the current rules before you rely on them, and if your business has a parcel contract, check what your contract says instead, because cover can differ.

Two practical points follow:

  1. Included cover handles most low-value orders. If an order's stock cost is well under the included cover, a successful claim can get most of the item back.
  2. Your claim depends on your records. Proof of lodgement, proof of value and decent packaging are what turn a lost parcel into a recovered one.

Worked example: a month of lost and damaged parcels

Here's a made-up Australian store that sends 1,000 parcels in a month. All figures are illustrative and exclude GST. Check your own postage and costs.

In the month, 4 parcels go missing and 3 arrive damaged: 7 incidents. The store sends a replacement each time.

Cost of one incident:

Cost line Amount
Replacement stock (cost price) $32.00
Second postage (say) $11.20
Packaging $1.60
Pick and pack $2.40
Customer service, 15 minutes at $40/hour $10.00
Total per incident $57.20
$32.00 + $11.20 + $1.60 + $2.40 + $10.00 = $57.20

The month:

Incident costs:  7 × $57.20  = $400.40
Claim time:      7 × 15 min at $40/hour = 7 × $10.00 = $70.00
Recovered:       5 accepted claims × $30.00 average = $150.00

Net cost = $400.40 + $70.00 − $150.00 = $320.40

Per parcel sent:

$320.40 ÷ 1,000 parcels = $0.32 per parcel

So this store should add about $0.32 to the true cost of every order, not just the unlucky ones. Round it to $0.35 to leave a little headroom. It looks small, but if the store's shipping margin is around $1 to $2 a parcel, it's a real slice of it. That's why the true shipping cost per order should always include an allowance for parcels that go wrong.

Two things in the example are worth noticing:

  • Claims are worth making here. Each claim took $10.00 of time and the accepted ones recovered $30.00 on average. If your items are cheap, the sum can flip: a 15-minute claim on a $6 item isn't worth it unless the evidence is already to hand.
  • The allowance moves with your incident count. Double the incidents and the allowance roughly doubles. Track it monthly so a packaging or courier problem shows up as a number, not a vibe.

When one parcel can wipe out a month of margin

The average hides the orders that matter most. Say the same store sells an occasional premium item: stock cost $260, retail $520.

Illustrative, ex GST. If that parcel is lost and resent:

Replacement stock      $260.00
Second postage (say)    $14.80
Packaging                $2.00
Pick and pack            $2.40
Customer service        $10.00
Total                  $289.20

Included cover (if the claim is accepted, at most)   $100.00
Uncovered loss                                       $189.20

If the store makes about $1.80 of shipping margin on a normal order:

$189.20 ÷ $1.80 = about 105 orders

One lost premium parcel cancels the shipping margin of roughly 105 ordinary orders. That's the case where Extra Cover earns its keep.

A simple rule for Extra Cover

On average, Extra Cover pays for itself when:

chance of loss or damage × uncovered amount > price of the cover

Using the example's rate (7 incidents in 1,000 parcels, or 0.7%):

0.007 × $189.20 = $1.32 expected uncovered loss

If covering that parcel would cost more than about $1.32, buying cover is more expensive on average than taking the risk yourself. Most of the time, it will be.

But averages only help if you send enough of these orders for the luck to even out. A store sending a handful of premium orders a month can't spread one $189.20 loss very far. So use two tests:

  1. Volume test: if you send lots of similar high-value orders, self-insuring (keeping the allowance, skipping the cover) is usually cheaper.
  2. Pain test: if one loss would cost more than you'd be happy to absorb in a month, buy the cover for those orders, and consider building its price into what you charge for shipping on them.

At the time of writing, Australia Post also sells Signature on Delivery and other optional extras. Signature can help prove delivery on valuable orders, and Australia Post's rules may require it alongside higher levels of Extra Cover, so check the current conditions for your service.

How to cut the number of incidents

Recovering money is good. Not losing it is better.

  • Pack for the journey, not the shelf. Damage is often a packaging problem, and inadequate packing can sink a claim too. A sturdier box or more void fill usually costs less than one replacement.
  • Check addresses before you ship. Missing unit numbers and typos cause many "lost" parcels. Flag orders with incomplete addresses before packing.
  • Keep lodgement records. Proof of lodgement is the first thing a claim needs. Keep manifests or receipts somewhere you can find them months later.
  • Photograph high-value orders packed and labelled. It takes seconds and helps with proof of value and condition.
  • Log every incident with the order number, product, service, destination and outcome. Patterns appear fast: one product that breaks, one box size that crushes, one area where parcels go missing.

Putting the allowance into your price

Once you have a per-order figure, add it to your cost per order with postage, packaging and pick-pack. Then make sure what you charge for shipping covers the total. A percentage or dollar shipping markup is the usual way to carry a small allowance like this without changing every rate by hand.

If you quote live Australia Post rates on Shopify, TrkShp lets you add a global markup and per-service overrides on top of the domestic rates, so a small allowance like $0.35 can be built into every quote. Remember that markup isn't profit: it only covers the allowance if your incident rate stays where you measured it.

Key takeaways

  • A lost or damaged parcel costs replacement stock, second postage, packing and staff time, not just the item.
  • Turn a few months of incidents into a per-order allowance: net cost ÷ parcels sent. In the example it was $0.32 a parcel.
  • At the time of writing, Australia Post includes up to $100 of cover on most services; claims need proof of lodgement and decent packaging.
  • Buy Extra Cover where one loss would hurt more than you'd happily absorb; on average, self-insuring is often cheaper for low-value orders.
  • Better packing, address checks and an incident log cut the allowance over time.

For a fuller picture of where shipping makes and loses money, read our shipping margins guide, or see how TrkShp works for Australian Shopify stores.

Frequently asked questions

Who pays when a parcel is lost in the post in Australia?

In practice the store usually does first, by sending a replacement or refunding the customer. You can then lodge a claim with Australia Post. At the time of writing, Australia Post says most of its services include up to $100 of cover for loss or damage, with claims assessed case by case.

How much should I allow for lost and damaged parcels?

Add up what your lost and damaged parcels cost over a few months, including replacement stock, second postage, packing and staff time, subtract what claims recovered, and divide by the number of parcels you sent. That gives you a per-order allowance to include in your true shipping cost.

Is Australia Post Extra Cover worth it?

It's worth it on orders where a single loss would hurt more than you're happy to absorb, usually those worth well above the included cover. On low-value orders the included cover often already covers the item, so Extra Cover adds cost without changing much.

What do I need to make an Australia Post claim?

Keep proof of lodgement and proof of value for every parcel. For damage, keep the item and its packaging. At the time of writing, Australia Post's compensation page also says items that weren't adequately packed aren't covered.